[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]

Re: Wikileaks is the Endgame



On Fri, 1 Jul 2016 19:55:42 -0600
Mirimir <mirimir@riseup.net> wrote:

> > Mirimir <mirimir@riseup.net> wrote:
> > 
> >>>> As much as I sympathize for victims of criminal states, I believe
> >>>> that anonymity systems are essential for protecting privacy and
> >>>> freedom. I also believe that they may eventually reduce state
> >>>> power substantially. Although that's seeming more and more like
> >>>> a dream.
> >>>

> 
> Yore reading comprehension sucks ;)

	I don't think so. 

> 
> Read the fucking paragraph that you quoted. It says nothing about Tor.

	Dude! Context!

	The whole discussion was about tor! And at some point
	you said 

	"I also believe that they may eventually reduce state
	power substantially" 

	"They" stands for "anonymity systems" which in this
	'context' basically means tor. Even more so since you keep
	repeating that tor is the best system 'we' have.

	So you say that 'anonimity systems' *may eventually* reduce
	state power, from which it follows that RIGHT NOW, THEY
	DON'T. And you further acknowledge that such reduction seems
	like a dream. 
	
	So you basically conceded my point. I simply reading your
	allegedly 'general' comment in a way that underscores the fact
	that tor doesn't work.

	Would *working* anonimity systems reduce state power? Likely
	yes. Do the current anonimity systems reduce state power? No.
	Especially tor, a creation of the state.
 

> It's about anonymity systems generally. That's what you're apparently
> saying is bullshit. Or have I misread you?

	Anonimity systems in general include tor in particular.


> 
> But right now, Tor is the best we have. 

	Yeah. You said so a couple of times...


> So we use it, with suitable
> precautions. Or we play naked. What else do you suggest?
> 
	
	I suggest you stop using the pronoun 'we'. *You* find the 'free'
	tax-funded pentagon's 'anonimity' network useful and apparently
	don't care much about the real price of the system. 

	I further suggest that anybody interested in freedom stay away
	from the pentagon. Doubly so if they are cypherpunk
	'anarchists' or sympathetic to the cause.